$5,740,000
5 bd5 ba3,500 sqft Water Mill, NY
5 bd5 ba3,500 sqft
Water Mill, NY
Sold 3 months ago
BuyerSeller
Get to know Justin Agnello
Atlantic Team
Justin equally enjoys the personal side of working with clients in every phase of the real estate process, whether the goal is to buy a dream home, sell a prized property, or rent a fabulous vacation destination. His exceptional service and results not only win clients' loyalty and repeat business, but are rewarded with wholehearted referrals. He is also well respected among his peers and enjoys great connections with agents in New York City, and...
Specialties
21 Years of experienceBuyer's AgentListing AgentVacation / Short-term Rentals
Justin Agnello's listings & sales (105)
For Sale
For Rent
Sold
This map can show the most recent 100 listings and 100 sales. Review all listings and sales below.
For Sale (7)
Address | Bed/Bath | Listing price |
|---|---|---|
 68 Fresh Pond Rd Amagansett, NY 11930
| 6 Bed, 10 Bath | $8,999,999 |
 12 Rolling Wood Ln East Hampton, NY 11937
| 7 Bed, 11 Bath | $5,875,000 |
 266 Hampton St Sag Harbor, NY 11963
| 6 Bed, 7 Bath | $4,495,000 |
 278 Hampton St Sag Harbor, NY 11963
| 6 Bed, 7 Bath | $3,999,999 |
 178 Skimhampton Rd East Hampton, NY 11937
| 7 Bed, 10 Bath | $10,395,000 |
For Rent (1)
Address | Bed/Bath | Listing price |
|---|---|---|
 319 Two Holes Water Rd East Hampton, NY 11937
| 7 Bed, 10 Bath | $195,000/mo |
Sold (97)
Address | Sold date | Closing price | Represented | Flag Sale |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4/28/2025 | $5,740,000 | Buyer and Seller | ||
| 3/28/2025 | $2,335,000 | Seller | ||
| 3/17/2025 | $2,500,000 | Buyer and Seller | ||
| 3/17/2025 | $6,250,000 | Seller | ||
| 11/20/2024 | $1,150,000 | Seller |
Justin Agnello's reviews (16)
Write a review- Highly likely to recommend||5.05.0
4/29/2025 - Eric berkowitz
Sold a Single Family home in 2025 in Bridgehampton, NY.Local knowledgeProcess expertiseResponsivenessNegotiation skillsThe Atlantic team was fantastic. We had a tough property to sell with complicated land restrictions and setbacks, but they never gave up. They brought tons of knowledge, stayed patient, and found creative ways to move things forward. Their persistenc... - Highly likely to recommend||5.05.0
6/19/2022 - KathyKaswell
Sold a Single Family home in 2022 in Northwest harbor, East hampton, NY.Local knowledgeProcess expertiseResponsivenessNegotiation skillsIt was a pleasure working with Justin Agnello and his Atlantic Team. Justin made the process incredibly seamless. His thorough knowledge of the local market was instrumental in selling our water front home in record time. He was wonderful to work wi... - Highly likely to recommend||5.05.0
6/10/2019 - mgreentenx
Bought a Single Family home in 2019 in Northwest harbor, East hampton, NY.Local knowledgeProcess expertiseResponsivenessNegotiation skillsJustin took care of every detail no matter how small. Also, always called backed immediately whenever I had a question. Always patient and showed us a ton of houses before we found the one we liked. Highly recommend. - Highly likely to recommend||5.05.0
2/12/2019 - Lisa Govoni
Bought a Single Family home in 2019 in Northwest harbor, East hampton, NY.Local knowledgeProcess expertiseResponsivenessNegotiation skillsWe had a great experience with the Atlantic Group. Justin Agnello was extremely trustworthy and guided us through each step of the process. He passed along great referrals as we are new to the area and was very reliable during the closing. I would h... - Highly likely to recommend||5.05.0
12/26/2017 - mhellman19
Bought a Single Family home in 2017 in Northwest harbor, East hampton, NY.Local knowledgeProcess expertiseResponsivenessNegotiation skillsWorking with Justin Agnello, the listing agent of our home was a pleasure from start to finish. Justin is energetic, efficient and attentive to the details of the buying process. As a local he adds the knowledge of having lived in the Hamptons his en...
